A Network Analysis Investigation

He Who Owns the Silence
Owns the World

Mapping the Architecture of Elite Impunity

Crumbling statue with newspaper fragments

Analysis prepared by Aureliano Vale

The name appears on page eleven.

Not redacted. Not hidden. Just never asked about. A deposition transcript, seventeen pages, filed in a civil case that settled before anyone had to answer anything under oath. The name sits there the way a bone sits in soil: waiting to be found, or waiting to be forgotten. It depends on who's digging.

That is how these things work. Not through concealment. Through the discipline of never looking. The documents were always public. The flight logs were always filed. The girls were always named, in testimony, in police reports, in the court records that no one reads because reading would require acknowledging. And acknowledgment has consequences.

Silence is not the absence of evidence. It is the presence of agreement.

When the Department of Justice released fifteen thousand documents, they did not reveal a secret. They revealed a structure. The architecture of looking away. The geometry of who knew whom, who appeared beside whom, who sat in the same rooms and signed the same logs and never, not once, was asked to explain.

We built a machine to read that structure. Not to find guilt. To find pattern.

The Question We Asked

Networks can form by chance. People meet at parties, work in the same industries, live in the same cities. Over time, connections accumulate. Some clusters form naturally. This is normal. This is random.

So we asked: is the Epstein network normal? Could it have formed by accident?

To answer this, we used a standard technique in network science called null model comparison. We generated 100 random networks with the exact same number of people (19,914) and the exact same number of connections (899,505). Same size. Same density. The only difference: in the random networks, connections were assigned by chance.

Then we measured something called clustering: how often two people connected to the same person are also connected to each other. In a random network, this happens occasionally. In an organized network, it happens constantly.

62.6% Epstein Network Clustering
3.6% Random Network Clustering

The random networks clustered at 3.6%, give or take a fraction of a percent. The Epstein network clustered at 62.6%.

In statistics, we measure how surprising a result is in standard deviations. Three standard deviations is rare. Five is extraordinary. Ten is virtually impossible.

218σ Standard Deviations Above Random

This network is 218 standard deviations from chance. Not one of the 100 random networks came close. The math has no vocabulary for this. Neither does coincidence. Neither does "they just knew each other from parties."

This is not a social network that formed organically. This is a structure. Built. Maintained. Inhabited.

The Names in the Network

19,914 names. 899,505 connections. Some names appear once, in passing. Others appear again and again, in document after document, connecting clusters that would otherwise never touch.

We measured which names sit at the structural center of this network using standard network metrics: PageRank (who accumulates influence), betweenness centrality (who bridges different clusters), and degree (who has the most direct connections).

A Note on Entity Recognition

Extracting names from 15,000+ scanned legal documents is imperfect. Our algorithms sometimes fail to link "Virginia Roberts" and "Virginia Giuffre" as the same person. They sometimes count "Johnson" or "Williams" as distinct individuals when context would reveal these are fragments or common names appearing across unrelated documents. The raw rankings contain artifacts: generic terms, partial names, legal jargon mistaken for people.

What we can say with confidence: Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell dominate every centrality measure by wide margins. Donald Trump appears in the top 10 by betweenness centrality. Bill Clinton appears in the top 10 by betweenness and top 20 by PageRank. Sarah Kellen, the named co-conspirator, appears consistently in the top 10.

The structure is clear even when individual rankings are noisy. Two people sit at the absolute center: the man who built it and the woman convicted of running it. Around them, a network so dense it could not have formed by chance.

Name Network Position Legal Consequence
Jeffrey Epstein #1 by every centrality measure Charged; died before trial
Ghislaine Maxwell #2 by every centrality measure 20 years federal prison
Donald Trump Top 10 betweenness; Top 10 PageRank Never deposed or charged
Bill Clinton Top 10 betweenness; Top 20 PageRank Never deposed or charged
Sarah Kellen Top 10 by multiple measures Immunity (2008 agreement)
Alan Dershowitz Top 20 by degree centrality Civil lawsuit settled

The pattern holds even with imperfect data: the people who faced consequences sit at positions #1 and #2. The people who have never been asked a single question under oath occupy the next tier down, still deep inside the network's structural core.

The Network

An interactive visualization of key figures by PageRank centrality. Node size indicates influence. Edge thickness indicates co-occurrence frequency.

Drag nodes to explore. Scroll to zoom. Gray nodes marked with * are NER artifacts (generic terms mistakenly extracted as individuals).

The Pattern

Donald Trump. Top 10 in the network by betweenness centrality. His name appears in documents alongside Jeffrey Epstein, Ghislaine Maxwell, and four of the women who received immunity in 2008: Sarah Kellen, Nadia Marcinkova, Lesley Groff, Adriana Ross. He appears in flight logs. He appears in victim depositions. He appears in photographs at Mar-a-Lago with his arm around a woman who would later be convicted of sex trafficking.

He has never been asked a single question under oath about any of it.

Bill Clinton. Top 10 by betweenness, top 20 by PageRank. Twenty-six flights on Epstein's aircraft, documented in logs the FBI has possessed for over a decade. Named in depositions by women who say they saw him at Epstein's properties. His foundation received donations from Epstein after the 2008 conviction. After. When everyone knew.

He has never been asked a single question under oath about any of it.

Les Wexner. The man who made Epstein. Who gave him unlimited power of attorney over a billion-dollar fortune in 1991. Who let him live in the largest private residence in Manhattan, a 21,000 square-foot mansion Wexner bought for $13.2 million and transferred to Epstein through a trust for nothing. The 2011 deed shows $0. Epstein signed both sides of the transaction. Wexner later claimed Epstein "misappropriated" $46 million from him. He never sued. He never explained. The Boeing 727, the "Lolita Express," was originally Wexner's plane.

He has never been asked a single question under oath about any of it.

And the victims?

Virginia Giuffre was deposed. Cross-examined. Her sexual history excavated. Her credibility attacked. Her name dragged through years of litigation while the men she named hired lawyers and issued denials.

Courtney Wild was deposed. She was fourteen when it started. She testified about recruiting other girls because that was how you survived in that house. She has spent fifteen years fighting for the right to be heard.

Sarah Ransome was deposed. She described being trapped on the island, assaulted repeatedly, attempting to swim to freedom through shark-infested waters because drowning seemed better than staying.

The victims testified. Under oath. On the record. Their trauma transcribed.

The men at the center of the network have not.

Not once.

The Architecture of Protection

Two people faced consequences. Jeffrey Epstein, who died in his cell before he could testify. Ghislaine Maxwell, convicted of sex trafficking minors, sentenced to twenty years.

In July 2025, Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche, Donald Trump's former personal criminal defense lawyer, interviewed Maxwell for nine hours over two days. She told him she never saw anything inappropriate involving Trump.

Days later, she was transferred to a minimum-security prison camp in Texas. No fences. No cells. The same facility that houses Elizabeth Holmes and a Real Housewife.

Sex offenders are not typically allowed in minimum-security camps. The Bureau of Prisons has not explained who authorized the transfer or why.

Senator Sheldon Whitehouse called it "possible violation of standard Bureau policy." The families of Epstein's victims called it a "cover up."

Trump has said he has the right to pardon her.

Four women received immunity in 2008: Sarah Kellen, Nadia Marcinkova, Adriana Ross, Lesley Groff. Named as co-conspirators. Never charged. Protected by an agreement signed by Alexander Acosta, who was later appointed Secretary of Labor by Donald Trump.

Jean-Luc Brunel, the modeling agent who prosecutors say procured girls for Epstein across three continents, was found hanged in his Paris jail cell in 2022. Like Epstein, he died before he could testify.

Ghislaine Maxwell was convicted of trafficking girls to "clients."

The clients were never named at trial.

The clients have not been charged.

The girls were the product. Someone was the customer.

How We Know

We built a knowledge graph. Not a spreadsheet. A structure where every person, place, document, and event is a node, and every relationship between them is an edge. "Jeffrey Epstein" connects to "Lolita Express" connects to "Flight Log 1997-03-15" connects to "Bill Clinton" connects to "Deposition Exhibit 47."

The Technical Pipeline

Step 1: Document Processing. Most of these files are scanned images of paper, not searchable text. We ran them through OCR (optical character recognition), software that reads the pixels and converts them back into words. Then we used natural language processing, algorithms trained to recognize that "Virginia Roberts" is a person, "Palm Beach" is a place, "March 2005" is a date. From 15,365 PDFs, we extracted every name, organization, and location the machines could find.

Step 2: Knowledge Graph Construction. We encoded everything in RDF (Resource Description Framework), the same standard used by Google's Knowledge Graph, Wikipedia's Wikidata, and the FBI's criminal intelligence systems. Every entity gets a unique identifier. Every relationship is explicit and traceable back to its source.

Step 3: Network Extraction. From the knowledge graph, we extracted the person-to-person network: 19,914 individuals connected by 899,505 edges, where an edge means two names appeared in the same document.

Step 4: Statistical Testing. We generated 100 random networks with the same degree distribution and compared clustering coefficients. The observed network was 218 standard deviations above the mean.

What an Edge Means (and What It Doesn't)

An edge means two names appeared in the same document. That's all. It could mean they were in the same room. It could mean one accused the other. It could mean they were both listed in the same legal filing. Co-occurrence is not proof of relationship. It is certainly not proof of wrongdoing.

But patterns in co-occurrence reveal structure. And the structure of this network is 218 standard deviations from chance.

Jeffrey Epstein did not operate alone.

The math proves this. 899,505 connections. 62.6% clustering. A network so dense, so interlocked, so impossible by chance that the only word for it is structure.

Ghislaine Maxwell did not operate alone.

She is in prison. The men who flew on the planes are not. The men who visited the island are not. The men whose names appear beside hers, exposed in document after document, are not.

She was convicted of trafficking girls to clients.

Not to herself.

To clients.

The prosecutors knew this. The jury heard this. The judge sentenced her for this.

Trafficking requires a buyer.

The buyers were not named at trial.

The buyers have not been charged.

The girls were the product.

Who was the customer?